Philoponus: On Aristotle's Prior Analytics

agrees with our Philoponus, with whom one anonymous scholion on f. 174r corresponds 1). Guil. Crönert described the codex. A. Gercke collated f. 124v—144v (p. 315,1—386,6). At my request, A. G. Roos again inspected the codex and collated and transcribed the scholia of the second section and the second book that correspond to our Philoponus or are signed with his name. cf. Z.

p. 1,5—10,25. 12 "who" omitted || "earlier" Z || 13 after "for" add "of the" || before "forms" add "the" || 15 "who" omitted || "is" superscript Y^1 || 16 "therefore" omitted || "of knowledge" corrected Z || 18 "both from" and the first "and" omitted || 20 after "on the one hand" the second "add" "for" || 21 after "being" add "or" || 22 "or touches—sinless" omitted || 23 "knows" || 2,2 "if" ] "and" || 3 after the second "of the" add "therefore" || 4 "according to the senses" Y: "according to the senses" Z || 6 after "which" add "also" || 9 "imagination" original: φανοστασία Z || 10 "it remains" and likewise v. 12 Z || "but", "if" omitted || 11 "it itself" || 12 after "therefore" add "from" || 13 "since it was necessary" || 18 "from the" begins f. 33v Y || "of the gnostics" omitted || 19 after "necessity" add "therefore" || 20 "or from opinion" omitted || after "imagination" add "to take the arguments, that is, the principles of beings" || 21 "greater" || 22 "that is, from opinion" they have || 25 "will conclude" || 29 after the second "dialectic" add "but" || 30 "in discourses" || 31 "always", "ever" omitted || "is true—is false" || 3,1 "of imagination" begins f. 203v Z || 5 "that" omitted || 7 "to discern" Y || 8 "it itself" || 10 "and" omitted || "they attach" Y || "happens" Z || 12 "they submit" Y: "having submitted" Z || "for" omitted || after "with" add "the" || "it itself" || 14 "he does this" omitted || "therefore" omitted || "ever" omitted || 15 after "connected" add "to be" || 18 "of this" Y || 19 "being connected" Y || 21 "but" omitted Z || 23. 24 "greater than that which is surpassed" Z || 24 "of the greater" u. v. Z || 25 "all the" || 27 "the particular phantom" || 32 "of propositions" begins f. 34r Y || 4,1 "might take" || 10 "ever" omitted || 15 "concerning demonstration" || after "dialectic" add "syllogism" || 19 "what sort of" Y || 21 "of beings" ] "these being" || 27 "the demonstrative" || 28 "simple" || 31 after "syllogism" add "to learn" || "let us say—it was necessary" ] "it is to say. Since" || 5,2 "first" omitted || 3 "it becomes" || 12 "of the demonstratives" || 12. 13 "in—of the dialectic" omitted || 14 "this the syllogism" omitted || "will precede" || 22 "and" the second omitted || after "concerning" add "the" || 23 after "for" delete "cause" Y || 28 "from the third therefore" || 33 "into the" || 34 "to dissolve" || "it" omitted || 6,9 "these only" || 10 "was in doubt" (the first "e" is not clear in Y) || 15 "products" in both places || "the" omitted || 17 "of it almost" || 21. 22 "they stated" || 27 before "concerning" add "to" || 30 "therefore" omitted || 32 "to the matter" || "shares" begins f. 35r Y || "to that scope" Y || 7,3 "the simply" || 9 "in method" || after "them" 6—8 letters erased Y || "we refute" || "of them" (after "this") || 11 "if" omitted || 12 "the true things" || "however, insufficiently" || 15 "to them" || 17 "the perfect things" || 18 "demonstration" || 20 "of it—instrument" omitted || 23 "but—25 it itself" ] = Vt || 25 after "under" add "the" || 27 "I shall say" || 29 "by argument" || 30 "I say" omitted || 34 after "and" add "the" || "the hammer" || 8,5 "to others" || 7 "not" omitted || 11 "the" begins f. 35v Y || "as" omitted || 22 "being present—being absent" || 23 "and" omitted || "of the logical without" || 25 "on the one hand" omitted || 30 "the whole makes" || 35 after "as" add "hand" || 9,2 "of the Stoics" ] "ics" in margin || 4 "part—instrument" || 6 "takes" || 7 "when" || 9. 10 "to be gathered universal affirmative" || 12 "ensouled" (after "therefore") || 15 "the" the second omitted || 17 "being measured" || "to the" omitted || 19 "to Parmenides" || 21 "for example" begins f. 38r Y, f. 209r Z || 23 "for example" omitted || 26. 27 "that—of demonstrative" ] "and the rest" || 28 after "each" add "but" || 29 after "having said" add "that" || "but also the" || 10,1 "therefore" omitted || 2 "concerning" omitted || 3 "for" omitted || 10 "the" ] "of the" || 11 "was" omitted || 18 "teaches" || 23 "in" omitted || "said" omitted || 25 "proposed" begins f. 38v Y.

p. 190,15—191,21 (f. 91r Y, f. 248v Z). 15 "the but" || 17 "impossible" || 21 "the" etc. omitted Z || 24 "he shows but this" || "will be a syllogism" || 25 "indefinite" || 26. 27 after "un-syllogistic" add "couplings" || 27 "the truth" omitted || 28 "for" omitted || "negative" || 191,2 after "affirmative" add "the particular" || 3 "takes" || 4 "making true" ] "negative" || 5. 6 "he takes himself" Z || 7 "in every" ] "again" || 9 "it is possible in every white" || 11 "but" omitted Z || 14 "lesser" omitted Z || 15 "if either the..." etc. omitted || 16 after "greater" add "the" Z || 17 "which" ] "that" || "all" placed before "are" || 18 "and if" || after "particular" add "and".

p. 212,5 sq. (f. 96r Y, f. 253r Z). margin "scholion" || 6 "in" omitted || "in none" begins f. 96v Y || 7 "for he says just as" || 8 "in a certain" begins f. 253v Z || "in the" ] "by the" || 8 "since—19 to belong to none"]

1) f. 144v titled: "Explanation of the second book of Aristotle's Prior Analytics by Magentinus." His name is found on f. 171v, 172r, 173r, 174r, 175r. The scholia of Neophytus exist on f. 176v, 177v, 178r.